Monday, March 8, 2010
3/5/2010 Katy Area HS @ St. Thomas HS Varsity
This game was an honor to referee, Katy are a top multiple school HS team in the nation, St. Thomas are a top single school HS team in the nation. This game was also filmed (very well) and I was supplied with a full team of referees (2 ARs, #4) and communication devices. This was my first time in the middle miked up - providing it's own certain challenges.
"Derek: If your touch judge is going to flag obstruction, he might as well flag off-side. And a deliberate knock on. Or maybe ALL knock ons. I mean, why not?
Ed: Because now it's getting too complicated. I dont want all that information, and in any case tough judges are not always best placed to make those decisions. For example, it might look like a knock on to a tough judge fifty yards away, but I can see the ball went through the guy's hands and came off his chest. The referee's got to remain the man who makes the decisions. His touch judges are there to help him out in a few vital areas - not flood him with information he doesn't need and can't absorb"
Final Score:
Katy: 3 Tries, 1 Conversion, 1 Penalty (20)
St. Thomas: 2 Tries, 2 Conversions, 1 Penalty (17)
Game Notes:
Film makes me look slow, I need to move around rucks more, and just run faster. I had a workout the day before this game, so I felt slow.
One of my touch judges was too focused on helping me, offering me too much information on situations I was managing differently. He then proceeded to miss the # of a player with clear punches and a stamp (shown on video) that he was staring at. I told him at halftime to make sure he was supplying information that was important and that I was sure to have missed instead of managed.
Also, first try off a free kick was taken about a foot in front of the 5 meter line. A mistake I made back in new england at Middlebury. I'm worried that I allowed that again. St. Thomas had the same marginal advantage later in the game. I'm not concerned about it having impact on the game, but it could have, and it's a silly thing to let slide.
One breakaway resulted from a bit of fringing/obsruction that I did not pick up on (saw this in video).
headsets and communication was aawesome for handling substitution and getting quick answer from ARs.
I was happy with my signaling, it seemed very clear. Sometimes I repeated the signal a few too many times though.
lots of turnovers at the tackle in this game. resulted from slow arrival of teammates.
2/28/10 Texas Division 2 Collegiate Championship: Baylor @ Texas State
"Ed: Players are good judges. They go onto the field expecting you to do your job. But they wont be impressed by your reputation, and if after five minutes they think, hullo, he's not refereeing that part of the game today, they'll be in like a shot"
This was my first time traveling to the Texas "Hill Country." Not going to rant too much about this, but I'd consider it a bad day at the office. Sometimes you just don't get through the players at the start of the game, and it turns into a mire of inconsistency (thought not technically incorrect). As a referee, any time you give out 4 red cards, you've probably had a bad day. Now the fight didn't turn out like the video above, but I imagine it that way for sure. The 4 red cards came from a scrum I blew up for a penalty. I had been having problems with a Tx St props binds who had just subbed on. He wasnt getting bound right and ended up boring/pulling down every time. I had already penalized him once, this was the 2nd time, right around the 60 minute mark. I went for the penalty, the playres stood up, and it was just a brawl from there. I picked out too clear malicious punches to the face (landed) from a Tx St. and Baylor player. One of my assistants (to ARs were provided to me for this game) picked out two other clear offenders in the melee. So, 4 players through and landed malicous punches with the intent to injure....that means....4 red cards. From there on, the game would be 13 v. 13. Post game I got the story for what actually happened to cause the flash point: Baylor hooker went for the hook in the scrum late (after whistle), nailing the oppo hooker in the face. He wasnt happy, punch one, then the party started and quite a few were thrown. So, 4 red cards, that means all those players arent playing on Sunday (final).
Texas State (12):
Tries: 00:35, 60:00 (converted)
Baylor (20)
Tries: 44:20 (converted), 75:50 (Converted)
Penalties: 5:20, 56:01
Notes:
quick try to start the game, lead me to believe might be a blowout
no wrap tackle by texas state, no dangerous result, no penalty
30 seconds later, no wrap tackle, dangerous result, penalty (against tx st).
1 minute later, Penalty for pulling player down in air (against tx st.)
Then a mire of offsides, side entry, tackler not rolling, and more high tackles. It was turning into a real penalty fest, and I was not happy. The teams were playing aggressive rugby, and unfortunately I didn't seem to stamp my foot down enough to prevent the illegal parts of the aggression. The game turned into moving from penalty to penalty for any variety of reasons, but mostly centered around fringing and breakdown infringements. I needed to card, but I couldn't pick up the key infringers nor catch them at an opportune time to throw a card. I would say I lost the game after about 5 minutes because of some delayed reactions giving penalties.
My diagnosis for my issues and high penalty count this game:
Delayed reaction to dangerous play penalties (players losing confidence)
Delayed decisions in general (not sure why I did that)
The players being really pumped for the semifinal championship, not wanting to hear the warnings from the referee to clean up their game - read: I didn't take enough authority.
My ankle being a little sore from the night before (mental block)
No good mental preparation for me
On Sunday I ran touch for the final which was a bit of a blowout to Texas Tech, clearly the best team out there. A very enjoyable experience.
2/27/2010 Westside Varsity @ Strake Jesuit
"Derek: If there's on law of the game that most players don't understand - in fact many have never heard of it - it's repeated infringement."
Ed: And it's part fo the Foul Play law, so the consequences could be serious. Mind you, I dont' suppose I knew anything about it when I was playingi.
Derek: What the law actually says is that a player who repeatedly infringes any law - not just the heavy stuff - must be cautioned and sin binned. Whether or not he meant to infringe is beside the point. He kept doing it, so he's got to go."
I received a call at 7:05 PM on on the night of this game "Larry, the ref for westside varsity v. strake jesuit didn't show up...can you get over their quickly? please??" I agreed, but I wouldn't be able to get there until about 7:40, giving me time to get my kit on and drive around the Houston 610 loop down to Strake Jesuit. I got on my way...
I arrive around 7:40, it was about 50 degrees, slight wind, and played on grass. The posts, as is typical for HS rugby, were at the back of the in goal area. A Strake Jesuit coach had refereed the first half of the game to a score of Westside 12 - 10 Strake Jesuit. Final Score, Westside 12 - 10 Strake Jesuit - I refereed a 0-0 2nd half, lets see what happened.
Notes:
yellow card given for repeated infringments to Strake # 6, breakdown. He, as any good flanker should, was making a real nuisance of himself, slowing the ball down. I had warned him to clean it up, less than a minute later, he found himself on the wrong side of the tackle and turned the ball over to his side - YC.
2nd yellow card given to Strake #12 for goal line infringement. Lied on ground, sat, stared at the ball for about 3 seconds, then decided to reach out and grab for it, prevented successive phase for Westside which could have let to try.
I found communication a little challenging at the start of the 2nd half, but the players soon realized a real referee was out there, and communication became a lot better. Unfortunately, still no tries scored. The two sides were very evenly matched as the game worked up and down the field well - just no finishing ability for either side.
Westside Varsity: 2 Tries, 1 Conversion (12)
Strake Jesuit: 2 Tries (10)
Ed: And it's part fo the Foul Play law, so the consequences could be serious. Mind you, I dont' suppose I knew anything about it when I was playingi.
Derek: What the law actually says is that a player who repeatedly infringes any law - not just the heavy stuff - must be cautioned and sin binned. Whether or not he meant to infringe is beside the point. He kept doing it, so he's got to go."
I received a call at 7:05 PM on on the night of this game "Larry, the ref for westside varsity v. strake jesuit didn't show up...can you get over their quickly? please??" I agreed, but I wouldn't be able to get there until about 7:40, giving me time to get my kit on and drive around the Houston 610 loop down to Strake Jesuit. I got on my way...
I arrive around 7:40, it was about 50 degrees, slight wind, and played on grass. The posts, as is typical for HS rugby, were at the back of the in goal area. A Strake Jesuit coach had refereed the first half of the game to a score of Westside 12 - 10 Strake Jesuit. Final Score, Westside 12 - 10 Strake Jesuit - I refereed a 0-0 2nd half, lets see what happened.
Notes:
yellow card given for repeated infringments to Strake # 6, breakdown. He, as any good flanker should, was making a real nuisance of himself, slowing the ball down. I had warned him to clean it up, less than a minute later, he found himself on the wrong side of the tackle and turned the ball over to his side - YC.
2nd yellow card given to Strake #12 for goal line infringement. Lied on ground, sat, stared at the ball for about 3 seconds, then decided to reach out and grab for it, prevented successive phase for Westside which could have let to try.
I found communication a little challenging at the start of the 2nd half, but the players soon realized a real referee was out there, and communication became a lot better. Unfortunately, still no tries scored. The two sides were very evenly matched as the game worked up and down the field well - just no finishing ability for either side.
Westside Varsity: 2 Tries, 1 Conversion (12)
Strake Jesuit: 2 Tries (10)
Tuesday, February 23, 2010
2/20/2010 University of Houston @ McAllen Knights
Full size field, softened from rain the previous days. Quite hot, 75-80 degrees and humid. I commend both teams for playing a good honest game and helping to keep the penalty count very low. McAllen were larger than the underpowered UH (missing players due to travel distance) and used their size advantage to great effect. UH got easily frusturated with their mistakes only to cause more problems for themselves- enabling McAllen to score some quite easy tries. The heat definetly played a part in this game - McAllen score 5 tries in the 1st half, but only 1 in 2nd half. The heat slowed the players down greatly as the game wore on.
McAllen:
4:06
16:00
25:00 (con)
28:30
38:00 (con)
65:00 (con)
Final Score: 36
University of Houston:
Final Score: 0
Notes:
near radius event
zone inconsistency
improved ruck straight down management
scrum management good - early drives and improper binding stopped before starting
contentious try was scored. I was not 100% sure of score, but quite confident. It was a muscle over try...need to be better prepared for positioning.
lots of offside at kicks
prevented UH quick taps on a number of occasions. Need to endeavor to allow this when they seem to want to go quick.
low penalty count - 14
2/18/2010 Kingwood @ St Pius Varsity
St Pius: 2 Tries, 1 Conversion (12)
Kingwood: 4 Tries, 1 Conversion, 1 Penalty (25)
Notes:
hard to predict st. pius / kingwood direction of play. found myself out of position.
pile ups were numerous, managed
too easy with penalties - assuming player innocence. Should have been harder to teach more. Game still went well - but the ball was slowed a little bit too much.
2/16/2010 Sam Houston State @ Texas A&M
This was a Tuesday night game, it also made the rugby news.
http://www.americanrugbynews.com/artman/publish/college/College_Make-up_Games.shtml
Chilly (40 degree) conditions - played at 8 PM on Tuesday evening in College Station. Field was marked with blue lines - but there were white lines close to the blue. This caused confusion for players trying to stay infield. Game was close for the first 10-20 minutes, but A&M dominated possession and the gaps began to open up for them in the SH defense. The game was played in good spirit, but at the 60 minute mark SH really started to tire and began to get sloppy in their breakdown play - committing several penalties resulting in a YC. On full time SH managed to score their first try, punching over a try after numerous penalties committed by A&M goal line defenders - a habit that A&M had no opportunity to show earlier in the game. Overall, A&M dominated most aspects of the game (possession, set piece), coming away clear winners. |
Texas A&M: 10 Tries, 6 Conversions (62)
Sam Houston State: 1 Try, 1 Conversion (7)
Notes:
"white" request from A&M captain before game. I was not aware of "Maroon" importance.
two charge down offsides against A&M
offside lines on far side of ruck crept up - should have penalized earlier to manage better.
white 6 kept breaking his bind on scrum. Not very material - but should have managed the incident to stop him.
need to think about A&M ruck management - became more and more straight down as the game wore on. Need to manage better.
felt very good about my scrum management - I thought I was accurate and prevented problems before they occurred.
2/11/2010 Kingwood JV @ Strake Jesuit JV
Thursday night game.
Chilly conditions (40-50 degrees) but very little wind. Game was played a football field with extended touch lines but was still quite narrow for rugby. Teams played a wonderful game. Both sides scored tries from good strong direct running and off opportunistic botched lineouts. On full time Strake Jesuit made an excellent break from their own 10 meter line looking sure to score. Unfortunately while being tackled and reaching out to ground the try...he knocked it on! unfortunate, Strake was very close to a draw. Kingwood came away with this close one - it bodes well for both programs having such enthusiastic athletes on their JV sides.
Strake Jesuit: 2 Tries (10)
Kingwood: 3 Tries (15)
Chilly conditions (40-50 degrees) but very little wind. Game was played a football field with extended touch lines but was still quite narrow for rugby. Teams played a wonderful game. Both sides scored tries from good strong direct running and off opportunistic botched lineouts. On full time Strake Jesuit made an excellent break from their own 10 meter line looking sure to score. Unfortunately while being tackled and reaching out to ground the try...he knocked it on! unfortunate, Strake was very close to a draw. Kingwood came away with this close one - it bodes well for both programs having such enthusiastic athletes on their JV sides.
Strake Jesuit: 2 Tries (10)
Kingwood: 3 Tries (15)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)