12:00 PM Cape Fear 10 - 40 ECU
1:15 PM ECU B 3 - 24 NCSU B
2:30 PM NCSU A 12 - 42 ECU A
3:45 PM Cape Fear/ NCSU MOTLEY 17 - 0 ECU B
I officiated the Cape Fear vs. ECU game, the last 10 minutes of the NCSU A vs. ECU A game (due to the other ref pulling his calf), and the motley game.
ECU has done an excellent job of recapping the play for the day, http://ecurugby.weebly.com/1/post/2008/09/ecu-opens-fall-campaign-with-victories.html
NC State took firm control of the the NCSU ECU game, the forwards supporting and providing plentiful go forward ball. NCSU's game plan, however, tired very quickly - it was hot and humid as hell outside. As NCSU's pack tired - ECU took quick advantage, running through the uncovered NCSU backline defence to score. ECU definetly showed they have some very skilled backline players - but for them to go further this season it seems as though they need to improve the organization of their game as their game plan seems primarily based on the athleticism of their backs.
NCSU need to diversify their game plan - it is too simple. They can maintain possession and work their way down the field - but the finishing ability is just not there. Phases off the side of the ruck will not get you in the try zone every time.
From a refereeing point my biggest question on the day was is a "ruck" a "ruck" when there is no opposition committed? ECU, being much smaller than many of the Cape Fear players, would often not contest the breakdown at all. Cape Fear would take the ball in, ECU tackler going to ground, Fear players would keep their feet coming over the ball forming what was most of the time an uncontested ruck. Uncontested either because a contesting ECU player lost his feet or immediately disengaged from the ruck having realized it was lost. Now, how long should I allow for Fear to play the ball before I call it out - as after all - there is no opposition so there is no ruck - no need to wait for the ball to "come out." It seams unreasonable for me to allow the ECU players to come around immediately - as they did choose to not contest - but what is the right amount of time? or should it be blown immediately?
Considering this situation in international and guinness premiership games the ball is generally played immediately, causing no concern like this. In lower level games, where players are less knowledgeable, this situation is more likely to happen, and what is the right decision?
Overall, the event was great. Cape Fear but on food and beverage for everyone and there were even a couple "zulus." The B-side boys from both clubs all showed up very well considering for most of them it was there first time playing rugby.
Overall, the event was great. Cape Fear but on food and beverage for everyone and there were even a couple "zulus." The B-side boys from both clubs all showed up very well considering for most of them it was there first time playing rugby.