Sunday, November 1, 2009

10/24/2009 Hartford Wanderers @ Worcester

45-50 Degree Weather, Rainy, and very muddy field.

the start of the game:
end of game

Within about 10 minutes both teams were wearing a very similar color...mud brown. Scrums were regularly getting repositioned to enable to players to get their safe footing.

Hartford had a distinct advantage at scrum time but struggled to capitalize on that dominance.

Worcester were given a yellow card at the 60 minute mark for repeated zone entry infringements.

The score was 14-14 with about 5 minutes left in the game and Hartford made a critical error ...throwing the ball to a "brown" "teammate"...a Worcester player who strolled in to make the score 19-14.

In the next few minutes Worcester took a shot at a goal to stretch the gap and end the game...but the attempt was wide and Hartford made a nice break up the sideline only to step out around the oppositions 10 meter line (game over).

FT

Worcester: 3 Tries, 2 Conversions (19)

Hartford: 2 Tries, 2 Conversions (14)


A few notes for myself from the game:


  • Missed a Worcester player reaching through to strip the scrumhalf at a ruck...I was busy getting the backs onside. When I looked back it seemed the Hartford player had knocked on.
  • The Hartford scrums were bothering me...they were so dominant. I did not pick up on any binding problems on my side...but the Worcester coach pointed out to me after the game that the loosehead was binding on to the arm and pushing down
  • The Hartford hooker had great timing, consistently getting his foot in front of the Worcester foot...unfortunately he could not get a hook and it kept coming straight bcak out. My only solution was to tell him to be better...his foot was not up early but it was very disruptive to continue resetting the scrum.

Friday, October 23, 2009

10/17/2009 Northeastern @ Army (West Point)

Army did a good job reporting on the game here:

http://www.westpointrugby.com/News/latestresults/09-10-19/brothers_start_strong.aspx

This game really tested my fitness. I had already refereed a ladies game earlier in the day...and traveled the hour from their to the West Point facility.

The score was 93-3...and I was running wind sprints. The Army boys were simply more athletic and organized, running excellent lines and breaking tackles all game. Army did test me from get go with scrum feeds and tackle law but I set the line for them.

I think Northeastern may have been a little offside during the first half...but the Army scrumhalf's delivery was slow....and even when I gave penalty advantage...Army would break tackles and score.

In sum, some notes for myself:

  • Fitness is good. Need more COMPETITIVE games at this speed to practice keeping my mental clarity up. My ankle performed extraordinarily well in this game, from the fans I heard there was virtually no limp
  • Need to be strict on the offsides as teams creep up while the game wears on. This happened earlier with the ladies and the Northeastern guys had the habit...it just did not effect the game much.
  • Very pleased with the openness and athleticism of the game.
  • I threatened a card by pulling my ref wallet out during the game. The player thought I had carded him and left the field. Future notes: do not take out the wallet, don't want the player to think he has been carded when he has not.
Hopefully I will make some video later.

Sunday, October 18, 2009

10/17/2009 Dartmouth Women @ Vassar Women

Vassar do a great job of reporting on their games:

http://www.vassarathletics.com/news/2009/10/17/WRUG_1017094317.aspx?path=wrug

From my perspective...at half time...I was very happy. At full time...I was not happy with my performance.

The 1st half had less than 5 penalties....despite the close contest the ladies were listening to my preventative instructions and abiding.

I was so happy with their legal play in the 1st that when in the 2nd half they started creeping up at the breakdown and not quite coming straight into the rucks...I was not quick enough to penalize it. As the 2nd half wore on the offsides and zone entry got worse and worse, eventually getting to the point where I was blowing quite a lot of penalties.

My problem with my logic: when the ladies started creeping up I needed to ping them immediately to let them know the standard was still there...I was lenient...almost rewarding both sides for their strong performance in the 1st half. Mental note: don't do this again.

Otherwise the game was quite exciting with one of Dartmouth's tries coming from inside their 22 and passing through probably 10 of their players hands...quite a spectacle, it reminded me of Ngwenyas USA v. South Africa try in the 2007 world cup.

There were a few questionable calls from the game...it was not clear following one scrum who took the ball in goal (need to see the video)....and I was behind a girl as she scored a try (whilst being tackled)....it looked as though she may have knocked on before downward pressure but I had no evidence so I awarded the try. There was also a scrum feed that went straight through to the otherside..I thought it had probably slipped through the props foot but from what I hear..it did not. This lead to the winning try so I need to make sure these errors do not occur.

Monday, October 12, 2009

10/11/2009 Vassar College Women @ Yale University Women

Great conditions, sunny, ~60 degrees, field slightly muddy. Field lines very faint.
A very hard fought match. In the first half the penalties mounted against Yale for offsides infringements allowing Vassar to pick up a try.

Vassar were vastly superior at scrum time, but failed to use that momentum to score tries...Yale were much better in loose play than Vassar. Lots of knocks ons this game too, not too clear why.

Yale scored a try at full time to tie the game at 15-15, missing the conversion.

FT Yale: 3 tries (15) Vassar: 3 tries (15)

10/11/2009 Cornell @ Yale

Great conditions, ~60 degrees, sunny. Field was little muddy, but not enough to inhibit play significantly. Field lines were rather faint.

In the 1st half Yale proved to be the more athletic side with most of their tries coming from breaks in the backline. Cornell scored 3 points following a dangerous tackle in front of the posts at the 22.

HT: Yale 45 - 3 Cornell

In the 2nd half the game was quite a bit closer with Yale picking up only 3 tries.
I commend both teams for their great sporting spirit despite the nature of the game.

FT Yale: 10 Tries, 5 Conversions (60) Cornell: 1 Penalty (3)

10/10/2009 University of Rhode Island (URI) @ Amherst College

Sunny, dry, 60 degree conditions on a beautifully maintained and lined field at Amherst College. Aside from West Point, I don't think I have been on a better rugby pitch in the Northeast.
Within the first 5 minutes URI ran in a try to the corner (converted), leading me to believe this game may turn out something like the 82-0 AC drubbing of last week...I was wrong.

After the ensuing kickoff AC fought back well, keeping the game inbetween the 10 meter lines. The AC attack and defense was frusturating URI as the boys from RI began giving away needless penalties for not releasing and diving over in the ruck, enabling AC to pick up 6 points. Then, at around the URI 10 meter line the RI boys got sucked into an AC ruck, leaving an overload for AC...AC used the space, beat the fullback, and dotted down in the corner in spectacular fashion (unconverted).

HT: AC 11, URI 7

In the 2nd half URI had more sustained pressure on the AC line and worked hard for a try muscled over by their forwards.
AC then fought back and also had some sustained pressure on the URI line only to knock the ball on just before grounding.
With about 3 minutes left in the game (score AC 11 - 14 URI), AC were awarded a penalty about 5 meters from the touch line and more than 40 meters from the try line. The referee was surprised when AC indicated they wanted to go for points! While setting up for the kick a strong breeze began blowing, but despite this, the kick sailed beautifully through the posts! a very impressive kick under huge pressure for any level of rugby.
This set up the tie at 14-14, but in the ensuing kick off URI won the ball, ran a couple phases, sent it out wide, and scored a converted try in the corner. A heartbreaking finish for the struggling AC and relief for URI as they scraped by with a win.

FT
Amherst College: 1 Try, 3 penalty kicks (14)
URI: 3 Tries, 3 Conversions (21)

Some refereeing notes from the game:
  • I think I may have been playing not releasing too tightly. Essentially if the defenders had their hands on the ball when the palyer hit the floor and did not come up with the ball...I penalized. After considering it post game, I think I was being to strict....the player should have the opportunity to play the ball immediately (especially with support arriving) before he gets pinged for not releasing. Subtleties.....
  • Also, I almost had a major f up. It was quite a windy day. URI went long on a penalty kick for touch. The ball went well over the touch line...I blew my whistle for touch. What I didn't see coming was the strong gust of wind which blew the ball back in field and dead ingoal. I went ahead and offered the scrum back due to there really being no question as to the result....but I must remember to not blow my whistle until it actually lands in touch. I made an error like this back at Rucktoberfest 08, except for the ball blew back in but still bounced to touch.

10/4/2009 Providence College Women @ Army Women

Army dominated the game in all facets. They took every scrum against the head, stole every lineout, and scored a try on almost all distributions of the ball.
The only Army downside was they had a habit of knocking on half of the kick offs. No matter, they took the Providence scrum against the head anyway.
The game was mutually agreed to end at halftime (40 minutes).
Final Score 74-0.
Army: 12 Tries, 7 Conversions (74)
Providence College: (0)
I commend both sides for their positive attitudes and play despite the nature of the game.
For a 2nd game (2nd 40 minutes as normal) Army put their B side out to play the Providence College ladies. This was a much more even match with Providence muscling over a try early in the half. Unfortunately, the Army B side's fresher legs began to show in the last 10 minutes as they ran in 3 tries.
Final score of "2nd game" Army 22 - 5 Providence.