Monday, October 12, 2009
10/3/2009 Amherst College @ UMASS Amherst
NEW ENGLAND RUGBY REFEREES SOCIETY
Referee Coaching Report
Larry Whysall
October 3, 2009
UMASS men (82) v. Amherst College men (0)
Match Description
Halves were 40 minutes. Weather was about 60, threatening but not really raining. Field was full-sized, moderately well-grassed and lined. There were no sideline ropes.
As the score would suggest, UMASS were totally dominant in all areas of this game. They were able to recycle the ball virtually without contest at the tackle and ruck. While Amherst were game, they were simply not able to defend against the constant pressure they were put under.
We had the opportunity for a full discussion after the game.
Overview
My focus was on the points which were emphasized by Jeremy Turner in his report from North Conway in May: pace and fitness and anticipatory management of the tackle and ruck. In both of these areas there was very evident improvement from the occasions when I saw Larry in the Spring (April at Amherst Women and the game on which Jeremy reported). While he still looks a bit ungainly because of a lingering (but diminished) limp, Larry was covering the ground well and was almost invariably well-positioned in open play. There were not many long movements, but when there were Larry was keeping up with them well. This was true right to the end, including a 70 m. movement deep in the second half at the end of which Larry was, if not in in-goal, within 2 meters of it. He clearly has worked hard on this aspect.
Larry’s approach to the breakdown was good and when play was close enough for me to hear I could hear him using good, concise preventative talk to ensure availability. There were virtually no unplayables. The few infringements were spotted and dealt with. This was perhaps facilitated by the one-sidedness of the breakdowns, and I would like to see how he handles a more competitive contest, but he could only referee the game he had and in this area he did it well.
Specific Comments
We discussed all of these points immediately after.
· Larry allowed several UMASS players to wear full-length underwear in violation of the IRB ruling.
· The UMASS loosehead was consistently preventing his opponent from binding over his arm, and sometimes using the advantage to force the tighthead down and in. Larry dealt with this for a while, but it recurred when he was not looking. At some point more forceful action, beginning with a FK, might have helped.
· The Amherst #8 was consistently giving up his bind in defense (hands on only). This was not noticed. While it really did not become material, it would have in a more even game and should have been dealt with preventatively.
· Larry sometimes shortcuts from the scrum and ruck. Try to avoid this—go with the ball. We talked about anticipating where the ball is going and beginning to move a bit earlier.
· When attackers are going for a pushover try and channeling the ball away from the side of the put-in, think about a quick two-step past the #8 to be better positioned to follow the ball into in-goal.
Because of the nature of the game and what I was trying to look for, I will not report in detail on other aspects of the game. But I do want to say that Larry had a very good game. Advantage was consistently signaled and well played. Primary signals were given promptly and were followed by clear secondary signals. Larry maintained his focus for 80 minutes of a lopsided contest and had a smile on his face.
Thursday, October 1, 2009
9/27/2009 Merrimack College @ Western New England College
Merrimack College: 7
The Sunday rain had cleared up by this 4 PM kickoff.
WNEC are a brand new rugby club, but you wouldnt have guessed it per the way they performed.
The game was competitive and hard hitting. WNEC won the game at scrum time, consistently causing problems for Merrimack as they were forced to clean up messy ball at the back of the scrum.
WNEC scored a few tries from the base of their strong scrum but struggled to finish off back line moves.
Merrimack competed well, scoring one try of their own, but struggled to get their moves going because they were going backwards at almost every scrum.
It is strange how teams from Springfield, MA always have strong scrums, must be something in their coaching or training, because the Rifles and WNEC are extraordinarily good at scrummaging.
9/27/2009 Framingham State @ Nichols College
Taken from: http://www.nerugbyrefs.org/schedules/match_report.cfm?match_id=5422
This match was played on an artificial turf field lined for football but with sufficient width (e.g. soccer outline). The goal posts were in the dead ball line. It was mild with light rain. Under the conditions, ball handling was difficult and there were a lot of scrums, in which Nichols had a slight edge. There were bursts of good, linked phase play from both sides, but lack of experience and over-enthusiasm kept these from becoming the pattern. Nichols and Framingham both managed to score one try in the first half. In the second half, with more possession, Nichols was able to keep the pressure mostly in the Framingham and score multiple tries, mostly from a set piece platform. The game was played with pretty good discipline and in good spirit. I was impressed by Nichols coach and captain who prompty substituted out the one real attitude problem on their side (the said problem had stomped and thrown a punch that the referee missed...but the sideline did not).
9/26/2009 Old Gold @ Hartford Wanderers
Perfect Rugby Conditions.
At the end of the 1st half the score was Hartford 19 - 0 Old Gold. Hartford were using their superior size and pace out wide to burst through the Old Gold defense.
Old Gold, however, did have a competitive amount of possession and were succeeding in attacking the Hartford line - knocking one try on in the process of grounding.
In the 2nd half, Hartford presumably were resting on their 19-0 scoreline as Old Gold began bursting through a tired Hartford defense. Hartford was not tackling as well in the 2nd half as Old Gold were successfully driving forward and off loading in the tackle. In a one of kind feat (for me anyway) Old Gold scored a try while taking out the goal posts in the process. As the Old Gold player drove forward with two tacklers on him they collided with the goal posts which proceeded to split and collapse on the players - certainly not a safe scenario. Nevertheless, Old Gold scored the try on the try line in quite spectacular fashion.
It was remarkably similar to this:
Hartford scored 1 try in the 2nd half, Old Gold scored 4 tries. With 2 minutes to spare Old Gold had taken the score to 29-24, but committed a illegal zone entry penalty a few phases after the kickoff allowing Hartford to boot the ball into touch to end the game.
A well played game in great spirits.
Hartford: 4 Tries, 3 conversion, 1 penalty 29
Old Gold: 4 tries, 2 conversions 24
I also had a bad mistake early in the first half of this game. Old Gold made a nice break down the field to work within the 5 meter line in the corner. The 5 meter dash lines were drawn quite long and I thought he made it into the try zone, especially considering how he downed the ball. I signalled for a try, only to immediately realize he wasnt in the try zone. I quickly changed to a knock on scrum Hartford.....it raised a few questions from the players and sidelines...but play continued. I could feel the player's confidence in my dropping after this but I told myself to forget my mistake and move on. I am proud to say that I forgot about my mistake and moved on with the game.....refereeing confidently.
Wednesday, September 30, 2009
9/19/2009 Coast Guard Academy @ UMASS Amherst
The game started with Coast Guard working their way down the field and kicking a penalty. Amherst responded by muscling their way over the line after a nice break in loose play.
Amherst then took an interception which was "knocked forward" about 10 meters and recovered under the posts.
Coast Guard then used their fitness and large forwards to create a break and offload out of the tackle to dot down at half time.
HT Amherst 12 - 10 Coast Guard
In the 2nd half Amherst and Coast Guard traded tries again - Coast guard scoring a nice one off a maul formed from a pick and go near the goal line. Amherst also scored a penalty kick.
Late in the second half Amherst scored another try to widen the gap to 27-17, final score.
Through out the first 50 minutes of the game the penalty count increased at a steady rate with the two sides struggling to grasp the concept of zone entry and maintaining their feet. This resulted in a high penalty count and stop start affair. There needed to be a firm explanation...along with a yellow card...much earlier than 50 minutes in the game. A yellow card was given to a Coast Guard player after a firm warning about breakdown infringements at around 50 minutes. Following the yellow the breakdowns cleaned up fairly well.
I also yellow carded a player for dangerous play, he took a player out in the air following a kick off. The coast guard coaches thought this was harsh seeing that this was the first dangerous tackle of the game. What the coaches failed to realize was what I heard the player say on the way to the kick off "If we're going to lose this game I'm at least going hurt somebody." Now, as a referee, I probably should I have said something when I overheard this - I did not - and the player proceeded to commit dangerous play and be sin binned.
I also struggled with the scrums in this game, they were uniquely unstable, wheeling and skewing every time. I tried again and again to correct this, even penalizing some boring - no improvement. After that game I found out one of the Coast Guard props could not hold his weight in the scrum well at all. After reviewing previous Coast Guard match reports I discovered other referees had a problem as well. As it turns out, despite the Coast Guards very athletic looking front row - they could not hold their weight well. As a referee, I need to learn that looks can be deceiving, there are bad fit props, bad props arent all overweight or too skinny for the job.
9/19/2009 Dartmouth Women @ UMASS Amherst Women
http://www.dartmouth.edu/~dwrc/SCHEDRES/F09sum.html
This game was a real pleasure to referee with the ladies being very receptive to my instructions, helping to keep the game's penalty count very low and give a good flow to the game.
The scoreline indicates UMASS were dominant, but Dartmouth did compete well - they just could not finish their drives.
I had problems in this women's game with positioning and running lines as I normally do for women's matches. This is something to continue to work on. I got in the way of a defender once, and slightly impeded a pass from a line out. In the lineout I had expected the Scrumhalf to throw the ball before I got by her, unfortunately I had moved so early that I slightly impeded the UMASS scrumhalf's view.
9/12/2009 Williams College vs. Williams Alumni
This was the Williams RFC first game setting of the fall, the University only began having classes this week.
As a result, many of the Williams B side were playing their first game of rugby ever. Prior to the game everyone participated in a short training session to get everyone on the same page. This enabled the referee to explain the laws at the breakdown and practice skills which are so often lost to new players (illegal zone entry, staying on your feet, hands in, scrum safety, lineout safety).
This short training session prior to the game made for a very well played affair - considering the skill levels of those new players involved. After 20 minutes the score was only 3-0 to Williams A. Williams were knocking on the try line's door for quite awhile but the touch line proved a strong defender as two corner tries were called back for a foot stepping out.
After 20 minutes there was a break to go over some aspects of the game for the new players. We continued play for aonther 20 minutes, "half time," then played a final 40 minute period.
As the game wore on Williams managed to string together some consistent pick and go phases to grind down the field. Williams picked up 4 tries with this tactic of offloading and quick pickups to make a final score of 27-0.
Following the game I went to the social with the teams. They held a fantastic kangaroo court and song session. I was even able to teach this college kids a little bit about rugby songs, teaching them Yogi Bear and some new lyrics to a personal favorite of mine: I used to work in chicago. It was a lot of fun to feel like I was playing rugby in college again, being idiotic and singing rude songs.
Here are some samples of my favorite songs: